How to Choose a Commercial Ice Maker
Ice type, daily production, bin size, and air-cooled vs. water-cooled vs. remote — plus what Q does and doesn’t install.
Ice is a food, and running out of it during a Friday rush or a Texas heat wave is a problem guests notice right away. The right commercial ice maker comes down to four decisions: the type of ice, how much you need per day, how much storage you need, and how the machine gets rid of heat. This guide walks through each one, using guidance from ENERGY STAR, the EPA’s WaterSense program, the U.S. Department of Energy and Hoshizaki.
Q Restaurant Supply sells new and used ice makers. See our ice makers page or call (945) 394-0396.
Step 1: Choose the type of ice
ENERGY STAR splits commercial ice makers into two families:
- Batch-type (cube) machines freeze and harvest in alternating cycles. They’re generally used for beverage ice.
- Continuous-type machines freeze and harvest nonstop, producing flake and nugget ice.
Common ice types and where they’re used
| Ice type | What it’s like | Typical uses |
|---|---|---|
| Full and half (dice) cubes | Hard and slow-melting | Restaurants, bars, soda fountains |
| Crescent cube (Hoshizaki) | Clear and slow-melting | Restaurant and hospitality beverages |
| Nugget / cubelet | Soft and chewable | Self-serve drinks, convenience stores, healthcare, schools |
| Flake | Soft and moldable | Seafood and produce displays, salad bars, healthcare |
| Specialty (sphere, large square) | Slow-melting and premium | Upscale cocktails |
ENERGY STAR notes that flake ice is used mainly for food displays, such as seafood cases in grocery stores and salad bars, while nugget ice is used mainly for beverages. Hoshizaki describes its crescent cubes as clear and slow-melting for restaurant drinks, and its chewable cubelet ice as popular in convenience stores, healthcare and schools.
Tip: grocery stores often need two machines, a cube machine for bagged or beverage ice and a flake machine for the seafood and produce cases.
Step 2: Estimate how much ice you need per day
Ice machines are rated in pounds of ice produced per 24 hours. Hoshizaki offers these rough rules of thumb:
- Restaurants: about 2 lb per customer per day
- Bars and cocktail lounges: about 3 lb per seat per day
- School and university cafeterias: about 1.5 lb per student per day
- Hospital cafeterias: about 1 lb per person per day, plus about 10 lb per hospital bed
- Hotels: about 5 lb per room per day
Multiply your daily customers (or seats, rooms or beds) by the matching figure, then plan for your busiest days, not an average day. Hoshizaki specifically calls out weekends and holidays.
Remember the other ways you use ice: food displays, cooling soups and sauces in ice baths, bagged ice for sale, and catering. Ice that’s been used to cool the outside of food or equipment can’t then be served. The FDA Food Code (§3-303.11) prohibits it, and §3-202.16 requires ice to be made from drinking water.
Why the rated capacity isn’t the whole story
Production ratings are measured at standard test conditions. A machine in a hot back room, or fed warmer summer water, will make less ice than its rating. Check the manufacturer’s spec sheet for production at higher air and water temperatures, and size up if your space runs hot.
Step 3: Match production to storage (bin size)
The ice machine (the "head") makes ice, and the bin stores it. They’re often sold separately, and you need both.
- Production is how much ice the machine makes in 24 hours.
- Bin capacity is how much ice it can hold at once.
Your bin should hold enough to get you through peak service, because the machine can’t make ice as fast as you scoop it out during a rush. A machine that makes plenty of ice overnight but sits on a small bin can still run dry at dinner.
Ice maker configurations
The EPA’s WaterSense program describes three main designs:
- Ice-making head (modular). The ice maker and condenser are in one unit that sits on a separate bin or beverage dispenser. It’s the most flexible option for mid- to high-volume needs.
- Self-contained (undercounter). The ice maker, condenser and storage bin are built into one cabinet. These are usually smaller, lower-volume undercounter units, a good fit for bars, cafés and small kitchens.
- Remote condensing. The condenser is installed separately, often outside, so the heat from making ice goes outside the building.
Step 4: Air-cooled, water-cooled or remote?
Every ice maker produces heat, which has to go somewhere.
Air-cooled
Fans move air across the condenser. According to EPA WaterSense:
- Air-cooled models suit most commercial settings and use less water, because no water goes to cooling.
- They typically need at least 6 inches of clearance around the air intake and discharge.
- They work best where the surrounding air is 80°F or less, and in clean spaces without much dust or grease.
The Department of Energy adds that each manufacturer puts the intake and exhaust in different places (front, back, sides or top), so staff need to know not to block them.
Water-cooled
Water carries heat away from the condenser. EPA WaterSense says water-cooled machines should be used only when the setting requires it, such as rooms that stay above 80°F or don’t have enough clearance for airflow. In the simplest setup, the cooling water passes through once and goes down the drain. Systems that recirculate water through a chiller or cooling tower use less. ENERGY STAR doesn’t certify water-cooled ice makers.
Remote condensing
The condenser goes outside, typically on the roof, which keeps heat and fan noise out of a hot kitchen or bar. It’s a good option when the ice machine has to sit in a warm, tight space. It needs refrigerant lines run by a qualified refrigeration technician.
For DFW kitchens: back-of-house areas can get hot, especially in summer. If your ice machine will sit near the cook line or in a space that regularly tops 80°F, ask about remote or other options that suit that location.
Step 5: Look at efficiency and sanitation
- ENERGY STAR: certified air-cooled ice makers have to meet limits on both energy use and potable water use per 100 lb of ice. Ask whether a model is certified.
- Water filtration: filters help reduce scale and protect the machine. Hard water speeds up scale buildup.
- Sanitation features: Hoshizaki lists sanitation features and good drainage among the key things to look for. Follow the manufacturer’s cleaning schedule.
- NSF certification: look for the NSF mark, which shows the equipment was certified to a food equipment sanitation standard.
Installation: plan ahead
An ice maker needs a potable water line, a floor drain or other drain, and the correct electrical service. Remote units also need refrigerant line runs. Q doesn’t install or repair ice makers, so line up a licensed plumber, electrician or refrigeration technician as needed. Measure the space, including height for a head-on-bin setup, and confirm clearances before you buy.
New or used ice maker?
Q sells both. Used ice makers can be a good value, but water-using equipment can hide scale and worn seals. Ask about the unit’s age and history, and look inside the evaporator and bin. Our new vs. used equipment guide has a full inspection checklist.
Find your ice maker at Q
Visit our Irving showroom to compare new and used ice makers, or call (945) 394-0396. Pair it with the right refrigeration for your kitchen.
Sources
- ENERGY STAR, Commercial Ice Makers: https://www.energystar.gov/products/commercial_ice_makers
- ENERGY STAR, Commercial Ice Maker Key Product Criteria (Version 3.0): https://www.energystar.gov/products/commercial_food_service_equipment/commercial_ice_makers/key_product_criteria
- U.S. EPA WaterSense at Work, Section 4.2 Commercial Ice Makers (Feb. 2025): https://www.epa.gov/system/files/documents/2023-05/ws-commercial-watersense-at-work_Section_4.2_Ice_Machines.pdf
- U.S. Department of Energy (FEMP), "Purchasing Energy-Efficient Air-Cooled Ice Machines": https://www.energy.gov/cmei/femp/purchasing-energy-efficient-air-cooled-ice-machines
- Hoshizaki America, "Choosing the Right Ice Machine for Your Business": https://www.hoshizakiamerica.com/post/choosing-the-right-ice-machine-for-your-business/
- U.S. FDA, Food Code 2026, §3-202.16 and §3-303.11: https://www.fda.gov/media/194741/download
- NSF, "Food-safe equipment – a vital ally in your food safety program": https://www.nsf.org/knowledge-library/food-safe-equipment-ally-in-food-safety-program
- Foodservice Equipment & Supplies, "Buying Used Foodservice Equipment Means Doing Legwork": https://fesmag.com/topics/trends/15001-buying-used-foodservice-equipment-means-doing-legwork
Frequently asked questions
What size ice machine do I need for a restaurant?
Hoshizaki’s rule of thumb is about 2 lb of ice per customer per day. Size for your busiest day and check production at hot-weather conditions.
What’s the difference between cube, nugget and flake ice?
Cube ice is hard and slow-melting for drinks. Nugget ice is soft and chewable. Flake ice is moldable and used mostly in food displays.
Is air-cooled or water-cooled better?
EPA recommends air-cooled for most settings because it uses less water. Water-cooled is mainly for very hot rooms or tight spaces without room for airflow.
Does Q install ice machines?
No. Q sells new and used ice makers but doesn’t install or repair them.
Do I need to buy the bin separately?
For modular (head-type) machines, usually yes. Undercounter self-contained units include the bin.
